Welcome to Casa Benedetto's
in Saint Augustine!

Casa Benedetto's proudly continues our traditions of fresh authentic Sicilian cuisine prepared from scratch that we learned to appreciate growing up in the warm environment of a large Italian family. Many pleasant hours went by in Grandma's kitchen helping to ready the huge holiday feasts we fondly remember. Rice balls, braisole, manicotti, pasta fagioli, escarole & beans, and clam sauce over linguini made from freshly shucked clams are just a few of our favorite dishes served at Casa Benedetto's.

Our homemade desserts come from the original recipes used in the bakery Grandpa Benedetto & Grandma Maria owned in Brooklyn.

Tiramisu, cheesecake, cannolis, Italian cookies & biscotti are always available. Holiday specialties like struffla, cream puffs & ricotta grain pie continue to bring joy to many customers who are familiar with these hard to find items.

At Casa Benedetto's we strive to make each guest's visit memorable. We love to take requests for special dishes which are not on the menu, and cater to special dietary needs. As we prepare our food to order we can adjust seasoning, make dishes meat free for vegetarians, and even have whole grain and gluten free pasta available.

You can purchase an Instant Gift Certificate or Contact Us for more information.

Thanksgiving dinner


Casa Benedetto's will be open Thanksgiving day serving a traditional Italian style holiday dinner. $25.95 per person Manicotti Turkey with sausage stuffing, gravy, mashed white and mashed sweet potatoes, homemade whole cranberry sauce or jellied,stuffed mushrooms,string beans marinara, bread,butter & caponata. Slices of homemade pumpkin and cocnut cream pie topped with homemade whipped cream will be offered at $5.95 a slice Selected menu items will also be available for those who are not craving turkey dinner. Please call early to reserve your seatings at 1,3 or 5 pm WE will be selling homemade pies and desserts for carry out.Please call for details and order early so I can plan ahead and make sure we have enough for everybody. Thank you and we hope everyone has a happy & healthy celebration with family and friends. Robyn